Parashat VaYetze Genesis 28:10-32:3
Haftarah Hosea 12:13-14:10
Dear TBE Community,
As some of you know, I was a guest author and panelist at the Twentynine Palms Book Festival this past weekend and Shabbat. It was a wonderful time to connect with new poet friends and writers and to share the passion and fascination for the desert, for writing, and for reading.
On my last evening, after the conference was over, I was having dinner at the 29 Palms Inn. I had brought a book to read and a notepad to jot down some thoughts. I was by myself, so I was seated at the bar, as is often customary – a dinner party of one is not favored by the hostess. It just so happens that I don’t mind sitting at the bar. I’ve always liked it. One gets to overhear a lot of interesting things.
Next to me was a group of people who had come to town for a wedding. It was their last evening, too. They were talking about family, relatives, and eventually about who was – or had been – the favorite child.
“I was!” “No, I was!”
The adult siblings seemed to be getting along well enough to have this kind of bantering conversation. Another person from the group, not one of the siblings, added, “Yeah, my mom always told me: ‘I love all of you the same, but you were my first.’” Meaning what, the person wondered aloud: Did she love her first child more precisely because they were the first?
Another person suggested that it was a moot conversation: Parents don’t have favorites.
“Everybody has a favorite!” one father shouted. “We just don’t admit to it. We say to our kids, I love you just as much, or I love you in your own way, or you are all my children. But we know we have a favorite. And our kids know it, too.”
Well, Torah knows that people have favorites. And Torah knows how much suffering can come from favoritism.
Rebecca loved Jacob, and Isaac preferred Esau. Because of this favoritism, and because of the deception and conflict that followed, Jacob is now on the run, heading back to the old country, Haran, where he will meet and marry Rachel and Leah. Or Leah and Rachel.
At the well, Jacob meets Rachel first and falls in love with her. But his uncle Laban makes him marry Leah first. Leah, who was not loved by Jacob the way Rachel was. Leah, who nevertheless made Jacob a father first, and who bore him most of his sons – Reuven, Shimeon, Levi, Judah, Isaachar, Zebulun, plus his daughter Dinah. That’s six of the twelve ancestors of the tribes of Israel, including Judah, the namesake of the Jewish people and our Temple’s patron tribe, Zebulun.
Rachel, Jacob’s beloved, is the mother of Joseph and Benjamin. The other four tribes were birthed by Leah’s and Rachel’s handmaidens, Zilpah (Gad and Asher) and Bilhah (Dan and Naphtali)
I often speak about how so much from the Torah narrative found its way into the liturgy, into the language of the prayers. Here is a great example from one of our regular and best-known prayers, the Amidah.
In the first blessing (Avot v’Imahot, the blessing thanking God for our ancestors, the patriarchs and matriarchs) we say:
Elohei Avraham, Elohei Yitzhak, Elohai Ya’akov, Elohei Sarah, Elohei Rivka, Elohei Rachel v’Elohei Leah –
Orthodox liturgy does not include the matriarchs, and only around the 1970s did Reform congregations begin to add “the mamas” to “the papas.” Conservative congregations followed in the 1990s, though a few still make adding the imahot optional. Today, in the official siddurim of all mainstream non-orthodox denominations, Rachel comes before Leah – though technically, Leah was Jacob’s first wife and the mother of his first four children.
Some say Rachel comes first because she was Jacob’s first and only love. Others say that she is named first because she was supposed to be his first wife, had Laban not tricked the trickster. Jacob never wanted to marry Leah to begin with.
A minority among offbeat liberal congregations, like Renewal, independent minyanim, a few unaffiliated Reform communities, make a point to reverse the order and say Sarah, Rebecca, Leah, and Rachel.
They argue that Leah was the older sister. That she married Jacob first and became a mother first. That she was buried, unlike Rachel who died along the road near Efrat / Bethlehem, in the Cave of Machpelah, with the other patriarchs and matriarchs buried there and named in the Amidah.
Others say there’s yet a different reason: They feel that by reversing the customary order, they are correcting, however symbolically, the favoritism that caused Leah so much pain. That it is a way of giving Leah the recognition she did not receive from Jacob.
Which brings me back to the conversation at the bar in the 29 Palms Inn: Whether we like to admit to it, we all have our favorites. Maybe parents really love all their children the same, but we all have preferences: We prefer certain people, certain personalities, certain ways of being in the world. Sometimes we acknowledge these preferences, and sometimes we pretend they don’t exist. And sometimes our preferences have consequences for everybody involved. Not everyone can be so nonchalant and bantering as the siblings I mentioned in the beginning of this davar.
In conclusion, I would like to leave you with some prompts for self-reflection as we go into Shabbat VaYetze:
· Have you expressed preference of favoritism in your life, and how have you done it?
· Have you noticed yourself favoring one person over another?
· And (how) have you tried to balance it out?
Looking forward to praying the Amidah with you tonight!
Shabbat Shalom,
Rabbi Julia Knobloch